Sunday, March 30, 2008

A master of spin

Give the editor of the Flint Journal credit, he knows how to spin. No straight talk express for him. (I'll post a link to the column as soon as they put it on the website.)

In Sunday's editorial page, the editor says adios to longtime employee and editorial page editor Mike Riha (a great guy, by the way).

The farewell to Mike column included the editor's new initiative to bring the paper closer to its readers by turning over more of the editorial page to contributors. So now the paper won't write editorials daily (Sunday-Friday) as it has but will let its readers fill in on some days.

This, according to the editor, is to bring the newspaper closer to its readers.

Better wear your boots when you read this stuff or you'll be up to your knees in what the cows left behind.

Here's the no-spin translation: "We are running out of people to write, I don't want to write everyday because I'm busy overseeing our correction policy and so we're going to fill the editorial page with your free stuff."

The truth is that readers and contributors don't ask for an hourly wage or benefits.

Here's how I would have written it:

"Folks, the squeeze is on. My owners have eviscerated my newsroom. I've already kissed off most of the coverage of Lapeer and Shiawassee counties and my business desk is gone except for one reporter. My features desk is a fond memory.

Areas that used to be covered by five reporters are now assigned to one. Some of them are new and need to get up to speed and learn the ropes. I can only flog them so much.

So here's the deal, I have no one left to write editorials and you people keep calling me telling me how you can do my job better. Here's your chance, I'm turning over large portions of the editorial pages to you several days a week.

But unlike the people who used to work there, you can't ask for pay or benefits. Deal? Deal.

By the way, sorry about that hefty per newspaper issue price increase late last year and for charging you to put milestone pictures and articles in the paper that we used to do free. Just be glad we don't bill you for putting your name in the paper when you are arrested. Thanks for reading."
This all fits with the new newsroom attempts to raise morale among the surviving employees. Recently the management told reporters they were looking for ways to make working at the paper more fun.

One actual suggestion: A bulletin board where pictures of family members of staffers could be posted to help improve morale.

Here's my suggestion: Pay people what they are worth and for ALL the hours they work. Overtime is nice too. Do that, morale will really soar.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Is the Flint Journal editor hanging out with Howard Wolfson, or what? The only half-truth the spinner-in-chief left out of his column was a reference about having to write his fluff under the threat of sniper fire. Too bad such insulting drivel was spewed in the context of a column about Mike Riha's departure. It must have been humiliating to end a distinguished 40-year career with a pat on the head by such a journalistic lightweight. It'd be like Sanjay from "American Idol" complementing Mick Jagger on his showmanship.

Jim,I agree with you: At this point, why must this editor persist on peeing on readers' shoes and telling them it's raining? It hasn't worked with the staff; why would it work with customers, who are also getting stiffed by the "new" and definitely not improved Flint Journal.

Good newspapers can get closer to their readers by a time-honored practice: It's called TALKING TO THEM. Not going to the mall and collecting soundbites on world events from knuckleheads, but actually going in to communities and writing about what's going on. I think they used to call that beat reporting. You can break some pretty interesting stories that way, or so I've read in the Free Press.

Getting out of the editorial business means that the Journal has given up the last shred of leadership it was exercising.

Who is going to ensure these citizen editorials are fact-based? The content in the news pages already is grammatically challenged, and we're supposed to believe that this "professional" content is produced and edited by educated people. It's only a matter of time before advertisers (the ones who are left) figure out that the paper is being subcontracted to volunteers. Now that's a hot bowl of Not Good.

However, I don't have a problem with charging non-subscribers to run wedding/engagement/anniversary announcements. Subscribers should get one "free" announcement per year. Business realities have changed: Airlines now charge for the peanuts they used to give away; heck they even set aside aisle seats in coach and charge above and beyond the ticket price.

Finally, Jim, you must be making up this "morale progam" story. Work people to death with no overtime and then make up for it by letting the exhausted rank-and-file put up photos of their families? Are you sure that wasn't a Dilbert cartoon? You know how demanding employees can be, though -- you let them acknowledge that they have families and the next thing you know, they'll want bathroom breaks.

Anonymous said...

Hey, we don't call him Tony Baloney for nuttin!

Anonymous said...

Tony Baloney -- I like it!

Jim of L-Town said...

Let's not get too personal. As I have said before, I don't think the bosses are bad people, just bad bosses.
We can disagree with them, and vehemently so, without being too disagreeable.

Anonymous said...

Baloney tastes good. The problem is that it usually has a lot of fat and filler in it.